Los Angeles
17 March 2017
Reporter: Barney Dixon
TMCH could ‘interfere’ with free expression
Academics and practitioners have penned a letter to top Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) officials, expressing concerns about its Trademark Clearinghouse.

The 21 signatories to the letter asked Philip Corwin, Scott Evans and Kathy Kleiman, co-chairs of ICANN’s generic names supporting organisation, which is reviewing rights protection mechanisms, to look into a “troubling tendency” to disregard the “delicate balance that domestic trademark law strikes between the business interests of trademark owners and the free expression rights of their competitors and the general public”.

They outlined problems with the lack of transparency related to the Trademark Clearinghouse database. With the clearinghouse exercising a “quasi-public” function, the group said that the public should be able to search its database.

“In the digital age, the concealment of these records is a momentous and unjustifiable retreat from transparency.”

The group, which includes a professor from the Stanford Center for Internet and Society, as well as staff and attorneys from the Electronic Frontier Foundation, also said that sunrise periods go “beyond the rights that domestic trademark law recognises”.

“Under US and most other countries’ trademark laws, ordinarily a trademark right only exists within a distinct class of goods or services—for example, the Apple technology company’s trademark coexists with Apple trademarks held by a bank, an insurance company, and a travel company.”

According to the group, these new protection mechanisms could interfere with free expression.

They added: “The objective of the new Trademark Clearinghouse was to protect the legitimate interests of trademark owners as established by trademark law.”

“We believe this objective can be achieved without harming the competing interests of other users of the domain name system.”

More trademarks news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Amazon to broaden anti-counterfeiting programme
22 March 2017 | Las Vegas | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Brands should not “rest on their laurels” when it comes to the new initiative
TMCH could ‘interfere’ with free expression
17 March 2017 | Los Angeles | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Academics and practitioners have penned a letter to top Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers officials, expressing concerns about its Trademark Clearinghouse
IACC president testifies in Italy
17 March 2017 | Rome | Reporter: Barney Dixon
International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition president Bob Barchiesi has called for further collaboration in the fight against counterfeiting before Italy’s parliamentary committee inquiry on counterfeiting
Criminal counterfeiters targeting replicas
16 March 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Brands are increasingly prioritising replica products in the fight against counterfeiting due to criminals' behaviour
China heeds calls for tougher counterfeiting penalties
15 March 2017 | Beijing | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Director of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce, Zhang Mao, said his agency is "paying significant attention to this issue”. Premier Li Keqiang has also weighed in
Alibaba bears its teeth at pet food counterfeiter
08 March 2017 | Hangzhou | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Alibaba has sued a Taobao merchant for selling counterfeit Mars pet food worth RMB 2.67 million ($386,500)
Alibaba’s Jack Ma lends voice to calls for heavier penalties
07 March 2017 | Hangzhou | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Alibaba Group founder and chair Jack Ma has called for Chinese legislators to apply the same level of effort to increasing criminal penalties for counterfeiters as they did when cracking down on drunk driving