Arizona
27 January 2017
Reporter: Barney Dixon

Copying Karaoke CDs is not trademark infringement, says court


Copying karaoke CDs onto computers for use in performances in no way constitutes trademark infringement, according to the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

The ruling, which came earlier this month, centred on Slep-Tone Entertainment, which lodged the Lanham Act complaint against Wired for Sound Karaoke and DJ Services, alleging that Wired’s karaoke shows used unauthorised “media-shifted” files copied onto computer hard drives from Slep-Tone CDs.

The Ninth Circuit affirmed an earlier decision from the US District Court for the District of Arizona, which said that Slep-Tone “did not state a claim under the Lanham Act because there was no likelihood of consumer confusion about the origin of a good properly cognisable in claim of trademark infringement”.

Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act sets out the remedies that can be sought when a trademark is infringed and introduces the “likelihood of confusion” standard for infringement of an unregistered trademark or trade dress.

The Ninth Circuit ruled that Slep-Tone’s theory, which argued that because the media-shifted files displayed its trademarks and trade dress when performed, consumers would be confused about their origin, “does not involve consumer confusion about the source of an appropriate ‘good,’ as that concept has been defined by the Supreme Court. Instead, it alleges possible confusion over the source of content.”

Although Wired may have created a new good by copying Slep-Tone’s CDs to hard drives, “it is still not a relevant good under the Lanham Act”.

Those who see Wired’s performances of Slep-Tone’s karaoke tracks would not be confused about “the source of the tangible good sold in the marketplace”, the Ninth Circuit ruled.

More trademarks news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
UK financial services hit trademark high
23 October 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
UK trademarks registered by financial services have hit a record high, with investment in financial technology a key driver over the last five years, according to professional services firm RPC
Man guilty of trafficking $2.5 million in counterfeits
28 September 2017 | New York | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A New York man confesses to planning the distribution of more than $2.5 million of counterfeit UGG boots
Unitary trademark should be pursued in the EU
20 September 2017 | Prague | Reporter: Theo Andrew
A unitary trademark, similar to proposals for a unitary patent, should be pursued in the EU, according to Gregor Vos, partner at Brinkhof
Kroger and Lidl drop home brands lawsuit
13 September 2017 | Virginia | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Supermarket rivals Lidl and Kroger have agreed to dismiss a trademark infringement lawsuit over home brand logos
Kodi hit by trademark trolls
12 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Kodi, the company behind the open source IPTV box software of the same name, has been hit by a multitude of so-called ‘trademark trolls’
BBC Worldwide partners with Incopro
11 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
BBC Worldwide has partnered with brand protection specialist Incopro to tackle the unlicensed online sale of counterfeit merchandise
Facebook a counterfeiter’s haven, finds IPO
07 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Counterfeiters see social media as a haven, with Facebook representing the most exposed location for communication about counterfeit goods, according to the UK Intellectual Property Office