11 October 2016
Reporter: Barney Dixon
Patents a “terrible fit” for software
Copyright is a sufficient system for protecting software and the patent system is a “terrible fit”, a US Federal Circuit judge has said.

The comments followed a ruling in the Intellectual Ventures v Symantec patent infringement case last month, in which the court found Intellectual Ventures’s software patents as being invalid.

Judge Haldane Mayer, who oversaw the case, said: “It is well past time to return software to its historical dwelling place in the domain of copyright.”

Quoting other cases, Mayer added: “‘Several commentators’ have ‘argue[d] that the complex and expensive patent system is a terrible fit for the fast-moving software industry’ and that copyright provides ‘[a] perfectly adequate means of protecting and rewarding software developers for their ingenuity.”

He went on to say: “[A] problem with software patents is that they provide incentives at the wrong time. Because they are typically obtained at the ‘idea’ stage, before any real inventive work has been done, such patents are incapable of effectively incentivising meaningful advances in science and technology.”

Intellectual Ventures’s software patents covered its Distributed Content Identification System, Automated Post Office and Computer Virus Screening Methods and Systems.

Both the Distributed Content Identification System and the Automated Post Office patents were found to be patent ineligible by the court, but the Computer Virus Screening Methods and Systems patent was affirmed by Mayer, who asserted that the patent was valid.

More Patents news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
European Commission to investigate Qualcomm
13 June 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Qualcomm is under investigation over competition concerns about its proposed acquisition of semiconductor rival NXP
Michelle Lee resigns as USPTO director
07 June 2017 | Washington DC | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Michelle Lee notified staff that she would be standing down from her post, but offered no reason for her sudden departure
Uber fires Levandowski
31 May 2017 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Uber has fired key executive Anthony Levandowski after he failed to cooperate in a trade secret dispute with Alphabet’s Waymo
Nokia and Apple settle new dispute
24 May 2017 | California | Reporter: Mark Dugdale
The settlement puts a stop to litigation that spanned the US and Germany and saw Apple claim in federal court that the Finnish company conspired with patent licensing companies to unlawfully extract royalties
Uber-Waymo dispute referred for criminal investigation
11 May 2017 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Judge William Alsup said the evidence against Waymo was the strongest he’d seen in 42 years
AST launches IP3 2017
02 May 2017 | New Jersey | Reporter: Barney Dixon
The 2017 programme will target specific technologies, including the internet of things, content delivery systems and networking
WiLAN diversifies in wake of patent licensing challenges
20 April 2017 | Ottawa | Reporter: Mark Dugdale
WiLAN is acquiring an internet of things company for $47.4 million as it looks to diversify away from its core patent licensing business