Luxembourg
15 June 2017
Reporter: Mark Dugdale

CJEU confirms The Pirate Bay does communicate to the public


The Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) has confirmed that The Pirate Bay and other file-sharing websites do commit an act of communication to the public under Article 3(1) of the Copyright Directive.

The Pirate Bay, as a peer-to-peer network that indexes infringing content, is engaging in communications to the public under the Copyright Directive because it is aware of that content and doesn’t take action to make inaccessible, the CJEU held in the litigation between Dutch anti-piracy group BREIN and two ISPs on 14 June.

In the decision, the CJEU explained: “The view must … be taken that the operators of the online sharing platform The Pirate Bay, by making that platform available and managing it, provide their users with access to the works concerned. They can therefore be regarded as playing an essential role in making the works in question available.”

The Supreme Court of the Netherlands, on referring questions to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling in the litigation, also asked whether website blocks are proportional responses to sites such as The Pirate Bay, which do not host infringing content but provide access to third parties, as well as whether they are effective.

But the CJEU declined to answer this question in light of its ruling that The Pirate Bay and other file-sharing websites do commit an act of communication to the public under Article 3(1) of the Copyright Directive.

In his recommendation to the CJEU earlier this year, advocate general Maciej Szpunar reaffirmed the proportionality and effectiveness of website blocks, which are executed once a court grants an injunction compelling ISPs to do so.

“It is not necessary that intellectual property should be absolutely protected, that is to say, that the proposed measure should result in a complete cessation of copyright infringements,” Szpunar explained. “It is sufficient that it should seriously deter internet users from committing such infringements by making infringement difficult.”

“Given the role of websites such as The Pirate Bay in the operation of peer-to-peer networks, there seems to me to be no question that blocking access to such a site would make it difficult or impossible for most users to find the works made available on such a network and therefore to download them in breach of copyright.”

More Copyright news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
YouTube value gap persists, says IFPI
21 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Licensed on-demand streaming continues to grow in popularity as record companies promote digital services, but the so-called YouTube value gap persists
One million illegal set-top boxes sold in UK
19 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
More than one million illegal set-top boxes have been sold in the UK in the last two years, according to a new report
ImageRights announces US Copyright Office integration
18 September 2017 | Boston | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Boston-based copyright enforcement service ImageRights International has introduced a dedicated copyright registration service with the US Copyright Office
Fair use for Australia could future proof copyright
15 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A “principles based” fair use exception for Australia could be more flexible and help to future proof copyright, according to Rohan Singh, special counsel at DLA Piper
NBA tattoos not fair use, says Solid Oak Sketches
14 September 2017 | New York | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Take-Two’s use of NBA players tattoo’s in its NBA 2K video games is not fair use and a purely commercial play to “enthrall consumers to the realism of the games”
Monkey selfie case settled
12 September 2017 | San Francisco | Reporter: Barney Dixon
The ‘monkey selfie’ copyright lawsuit has been settled out of court, after both PETA and photographer David Slater reached an agreement to end the litigation
YouTube not required to reveal IPs
11 September 2017 | Frankfurt | Reporter: Barney Dixon
YouTube cannot be forced to reveal the IP addresses of movie pirates, but must provide victims of copyright infringement with infringers’ email addresses, according to a ruling from a German high court