23 March 2017
Reporter: Barney Dixon

FilmOn X fails to get judicial support

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has dismissed online service FilmOn X’s attempt to obtain a compulsory licence to the works it retransmits, finding it unable to be regarded as a ‘cable provider’ under the Copyright Act.

In another win for TV networks against retransmission technology, the Ninth Circuit rejected FilmOn’s claims that it still met the definition of a cable system despite transmitting over the internet, in its 21 March decision.

FilmOn had sought protection under Section 111 of the Copyright Act, which allows cable providers to retransmit “a performance or display of a work” that had been originally broadcast by someone else, so long as it pays a statutory fee to the Copyright Office.

But the Ninth Circuit said that when Section 111 was enacted in 1976, the cable industry “was a fledgling one”.

Congress responded to “economic conditions by enacting Section 111, which relieved cable systems of the need to sit down with every copyright holder before retransmitting their copyrighted broadcast works”.

“One could reasonably conclude that extending Section 111 to internet-based retransmission services would not further, and might in fact jeopardise” the values with which it was designed for,” the Ninth Circuit said.

FilmOn’s case follows the Supreme Court’s decision against online TV service Aereo in 2014.

The Supreme Court ultimately said that Aereo violated the public performance provision of the Copyright Act, which put an end to the online TV service and its use of arrays of thousands of tiny antennas to capture over-the-air transmissions.

More Copyright news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
APLA and French police take down piracy site
14 December 2017 | Bordeaux | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A joint operation between French police and the ALPA has resulted in the closure of piracy streaming website,
PSNI, HMRC and FACT seize 50 illegal streaming devices
08 December 2017 | Belfast | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A joint operation between UK enforcement bodies has resulted in the seizure of 50 illegal streaming devices
EU piracy guidance provides “no solutions”, says IFPI
01 December 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Barney Dixon
New guidance adopted by the EU against piracy recognises the problems facing rightsholders, but provides “no solutions” according to the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry
Cloud-based recordings require rightsholder consent, says CJEU
29 November 2017 | Luxembourg | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Copies of TV programmes saved in the cloud must be authorised by the copyright holder, the Court of Justice of the EU has ruled
Fake remembrance merchandise seized by UK Border Force
13 November 2017 | Tilbury | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Fake poppy branded jewellery, worth around £150,000, was seized ahead of Remembrance Sunday by the UK Border Force
Sci-Hub blocked in the US
06 November 2017 | Virginia | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Sci-Hub has been blocked in the US and must pay $4.8 million to the American Chemical Society after a US district court entered a default judgment and injunction against it
Duo arrested for Nintendo circumvention
03 November 2017 | London | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A man and a woman from Kidderminster have been arrested for selling circumvention devices that allow users to illegally access hundreds of pirate copies of Nintendo games