Los Angeles
22 March 2017
Reporter: Barney Dixon

Owner of .feedback lacks transparency


The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) has ruled that .feedback owner Top Level Spectrum (TLS) is in breach of its registry agreement.

In an unprecedented review by a standing panel of the public interest commitments dispute resolution policy, ICANN found that TLS engaged in conduct that “violated its commitments to operate .feedback in a clear and transparent manner”.

Last year, Adobe and Facebook were among several brands demanding an investigation into TLS.

They argued that the registry had perpetrated “deceptive practices in the .feedback top level domain in violation of its public interest commitments”.

The brands accused TLS of self allocating numerous domain names corresponding to brands, many of which were withheld during the TLD’s sunrise period.

This prevented brand owners from registering these domains that were then allegedly offered to others for “dirt cheap”.

At the time, TLS owner Jay Westerdal said the accusations were “wild” and “baseless”.

TLS is operated in an open manner consistent with general principles of openness and non-discrimination ... This is the first complaint we have seen regarding .feedback not being open,” he said.

“These companies have not reached out to us directly to resolve their complaint.”

But ICANN said TLS was non-compliant in several areas, and failed to be consistent with “general principles of openness and non-discrimination by establishing, publishing and adhering to clear registration policies”.

ICANN said that TLS must fix these breaches by 15 April, or it may commence the agreement termination process.

In a statement, Westerdal said that TLS is "disappointed in a number of factors of the ruling".

"First, the panel confused policy with marketing programmes. ICANN is not in the business of ruling on marketing programmes and the programme was outside of the scope of a public interest commitment."

"Second, for the things identified in the notice, we have already cured 80 percent. We add links and more detail to our website. We are confident that we will cure the remaining issues before April.”

He added: "In the end, it would have been more helpful to the complaint had they chosen to reach out to the registry. Instead they choose to circumvent outreach and constructive dialogue and tried to use a nuclear weapon of complaining to ICANN."

Brian Winterfeldt, partner at Mayer Brown, thinks the decision did not go far enough. “We are disappointed that ICANN did not address TLS’s many false and deceptive marketing practices, which are ongoing and continue to harm the complainants and consumers.”

Winterfeldt said that ICANN “must be accountable” for registries under its control and that its decision not to take corrective action against registries that violate the public interest commitment may “embolden others in this space to adopt similar marketing practices and strategies”.

“By failing to address fraudulent activity by registry operators, ICANN risks undermining the stability and security of the internet and the domain name system as a whole,” he said.

More Copyright news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Radiohead sue Lana Del Rey for copyright infringement
8 January 2018 | New York | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Radiohead are suing Lana Del Rey for copyright infringement, claiming that the Del Rey’s 2017 song Get Free was similar to their 1992 song Creep
Glosfer and Gemmy to create blockchain copyright protection platform
4 January 2018 | Seoul | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Blockchain firm Glosfer has signed a memorandum of understanding with copyright protection company Gemmy to create a blockchain-based copyright protection platform
Dish Network sues IPTV providers
4 January 2018 | Maryland | Reporter: Barney Dixon
US satellite TV network Dish has sued two IPTV providers, claiming that they profit from the unlawful retransmission of Dish TV channels
Spotify sued for $1.6 billion over copyrighted works
3 January 2018 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Spotify has been sued for $1.6 billion by Wixen Music Publishing, which represents artists including Tom Petty, Neil Young and the Beach Boys
Facebook slams infringing content in first half of 2017
19 December 2017 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Facebook removed more than 2.5 million pieces of copyright infringing content across its Facebook and Instagram social media platforms in the first half of 2017, according to the company’s annual transparency report
APLA and French police take down piracy site
14 December 2017 | Bordeaux | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A joint operation between French police and the ALPA has resulted in the closure of piracy streaming website, artv.watch
PSNI, HMRC and FACT seize 50 illegal streaming devices
08 December 2017 | Belfast | Reporter: Barney Dixon
A joint operation between UK enforcement bodies has resulted in the seizure of 50 illegal streaming devices