04 October 2017
Reporter: Barney Dixon

Google not liable for image search thumbnails

Google’s image search does not exploit copyright by showing thumbnails of copyright infringing images, the German Federal Court of Justice has ruled.

The ruling comes after Adult website Perfect 10 sued AOL Germany, which has a search function powered by Google, for showing thumbnails of infringing Perfect 10 images that had been published illegally.

Certain parts of Perfect 10’s content can only be accessed by registered users after paying a fee, but some of this content was posted online to freely accessible websites. If the correct terms were searched, AOL’s image results would show the thumbnails of the infringing images and link to the website the image was published on.

In the court case, Perfect 10 claimed that it was owed damages from AOL for copyright infringement, however the court disagreed, and ruled that AOL did not infringe Perfect 10’s copyright by merely displaying thumbnails of the photographs.

In its ruling, the German court referenced the Court of Justice of the European Union’s decision in GS Media v Sanoma in September 2016, which held that it is not infringement of copyright to hyperlink to work published online without the copyright owner’s consent, as long as the link was not posted for profit and the linker did not have knowledge that the work was originally published legally.

According to the court, an assessment of infringement is based on the assumption that the person places the links with the intent to make a profit. However for AOL and, by extension, Google, this is not the case due to the particular importance of internet search services for the functionality of the internet.

It ruled that the provider of a search function should not be expected to check whether the images found by the search engine in its automated procedure have been legally posted before they are presented as a preview.

More news
The latest news from IPPro The Internet
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Delta claims "confusingly similar" domain
22 January 2018 | Minneapolis | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Delta Airlines has claimed 27 domains in a UDRP dispute at the Alternative Dispute Resolution Forum.
Brinks, Gilson & Lione elects new president
19 January 2018 | Chiacgo | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Brinks, Gilson & Lione has elected a new president to succeed James Sobieraj
TWiT sues Twitter for trademark infringement
18 January 2018 | California | Reporter: Barney Dixon, is suing Twitter for breach of contract, unfair competition and trademark infringement, stemming from a deal the two companies made in 2007
INTA wins in domain dispute
17 January 2018 | Minneapolis | Reporter: Barney Dixon
INTA has won a domain dispute at the Alternative Dispute Resolution Forum over
Akerman hires new partners
16 January 2018 | Los Angeles | Reporter: Barney Dixon
US law firm Akerman has strengthened its intellectual property and commercial litigation practices with the hire of two partners
Alibaba refutes Notorious Markets report
15 January 2018 | Hangzhou | Reporter: Barney Dixon
Alibaba has issued a point by point refutation against allegations levelled at its Taobao platform in the US Trade Representative’s 2017 Special 301 Out-of-Cycle Review of Notorious Markets
USTR targets Taobao in Notorious Markets review
12 January 2018 | Washington DC | Reporter: Barney Dixon
US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer has revealed the findings of his office’s 2017 Special 301 Out-of-Cycle Review of Notorious Markets, including accusations against Alibaba’s Taobao ecommerce platform